Conclusions
Spider is an ambitious attempt at an enthusiast platform, and while Phenom and the Radeon HD 3800 series might grab all the headlines, the 790FX chipset is undoubtedly a key component of the overall equation. With support for HyperTransport 3 and second generation PCI Express, the 790FX has the high-bandwidth connectivity needed to fully exploit Phenom processors on one end and Radeon HD 3800 series graphics cards on the other. In fact, the 790FX is the only chipset currently on the market that fully supports all the features packed into new Phenom processors. Couple that with excellent OverDrive tweaking and overclocking software that we're told will be widely-supported by motherboard makers, and the 790FX looks pretty good.
Except for one or two not so minor problems.
Despite being the first new enthusiast chipset for AM2 processors in more than a year and a half, the 790FX relies on a dated SB600 south bridge chip whose limited connectivity options hardly befit a cutting-edge enthusiast platform. The SB600's comparatively poor PCI and USB performance only make matters worse. With a new SB700 south bridge due to arrive early next year on a second wave of 790FX boards, it's hard to get excited about current implementations.
The first crop of 790FX boards certainly has its share of problems, too. Gigabyte's GA-MA790FX-DQ6 suffers from a number of BIOS-related issues that really need to be fixed before we would even consider recommending the board. And it's not like this is a pre-release product whose kinks are still being worked out; the DQ6 was selling online before the 790FX officially launched. The DQ6 also suffers from a poor graphics slot layout and alarmingly high power consumption given the 790FX's 10W TDP. It's not cheap, either. With street prices currently hovering around $270, the DQ6 costs nearly as much as the fastest Phenom you can buy.
Our problems with 790FX motherboards haven't been limited to Gigabyte, either. We haven't yet had the opportunity to test MSI's riff on the Spider platform, but we've found Asus' M3A32-MVP Deluxe to have numerous BIOS-related issues and questionable stability. The fact that the top two mobo makers can't get their initial 790FX offerings dialed for the chipset's launch doesn't give us a lot of faith in the platform.
I'm not even convinced there will be much demand for a high-end Phenom chipset. The processor's performance isn't compelling enough to inspire current Core 2 users to jump ship, and those running Socket AM2 processors will probably be more inclined to drop a Phenom into their existing motherboards rather than going out and buying new ones.
In the end, the 790FX is a bandwidth-rich new north bridge chip held back by a dated south bridge and flaky motherboard implementations. AMD will have to do better if it expects the Spider platform to take off with enthusiasts. In its current state, we simply can't recommend the 790FX.

71 comments — Last by DaveBaumann at 1:34 PM on 11/28/07
| Sandy Bridge-E motherboards from Asus, Gigabyte, Intel, and MSIThe X79 Express cometh | 31 | |
| Llano motherboards from Asus, Gigabyte, and MSIIntroducing the A75 Fusion controller hub | 20 | |
| Bulldozer mobos from Asus and MSI: Sabertooth 990FX & 990FXA-GD80Socket AM3+ arrives alongside AMD's 990FX chipset | 53 | |
| Z68 Express motherboards from Asus, Gigabyte, and MSISandy Bridge finally gets the chipset it deserves | 58 | |
| Zotac's H67-ITX motherboardSandy Bridge goes Mini-ITX | 31 | |
| A quick look at chipset PCI Express performanceThe P67 brings PCIe 2.0 up to full speed | 57 | |
| Sandy Bridge motherboards from Asus, Gigabyte, Intel, and MSIIntroducing the P67 Express | 61 | |
| Asus details Sandy Bridge motherboard lineupLoads of 6-series goodness on the way | 41 |
| Friday night topic: The trouble with Best Buy | 151 |