Personal computing discussed
Moderators: renee, JustAnEngineer
JohnC wrote:You're doing it wrong. Spend a little bit more for a good Synology NAS. You'll get much more compact device, with unbeatable power consumption and very good built-in management tools (as well as mobile apps).
CampinCarl wrote:I suggest using FreeNAS and ZFS. I built a low end AMD system (A4-5300, Gigabyte GA-F2A85XM-D3H, 8GB RAM) plus 3 2TB WD Green drives late last year, and it's been rock solid ever since. I admit that I don't have power usage statistics for it, but I've had no problems just using an old flash drive for the host OS (though I would suggest a small SSD for the OS + ZIL, it's much faster). RAID-Z is pretty fantastic, and I end up much more limited by the gigabit networking (or the wireless) speed than anything else for most file transfers.
For what it's worth, the system cost me like $160, plus $85 each drive. That comes in under your $500 suggestion, and gets you an extra 2TB of storage. FreeNAS is super easy to use, and the web administrative interface is snappy and fully featured. Easy to set up CIFS, AFS, and NFS shares so if you have a variety of OS' on your network, you can have proper shares for each ecosystem.
HallofFamer wrote:I also haven't decided on the OS. I have experience with ubuntu server, but I have also read about freeNAS. I'm not fond of dedicating a hard drive to the OS or plugging in a USB stick all the time. Looking to do RAID 1 w/ 2x2TB.
just brew it! wrote:If you're committed to rolling your own box, and you already know how to administer Ubuntu Server, OS selection sounds like a no-brainer to me.
kc77 wrote:Please excuse the phone photo. I haven't been able to find my camera in quite a while.
just brew it! wrote:kc77 wrote:Please excuse the phone photo. I haven't been able to find my camera in quite a while.
Ahh, I gather that your "geek cave" is about as well-organized as mine is. I occasionally lose stuff in the mess for weeks at a time too.
Aside: Earlier this evening, one of the old UPSes at the far corner of my home office started screaming about its battery needing replacement. Physically accessing it involved excavating a tunnel under the table in the middle of the office wide enough for me to crawl through; it's probably been around a year since I touched any of the equipment running in that corner. I thought that UPS was the one running the web server, but it turned out that only the DSL modem and a couple of network switches were plugged into it. Moved everything to the other UPS located in that sector (the one the web server is *actually* plugged into) and called it a day. I'll probably just junk that UPS instead of replacing the battery again; it's an old 500VA APC I've had since forever.
Flying Fox wrote:Actually what is the problem with plugging in a USB drive? Just the unsightly nature of a stick outside the case? You can always get something internal and tape the stick inside the case.
Flying Fox wrote:Actually what is the problem with plugging in a USB drive? Just the unsightly nature of a stick outside the case? You can always get something internal and tape the stick inside the case.
HallofFamer wrote:
just brew it! wrote:Maybe the Memorex thumbdrives are OK. I've been avoiding Memorex products on principle, due to every other Memorex product I've bought in the past decade or so massively sucking (optical drives, optical media, MP3 player, etc...)
My overall impression of them is "rebrander of cheap Chinese junk".
HallofFamer wrote:Can anyone make a suggestion for/against using ECC memory with a ZFS FreeNAS build? I've read some strongly cautionary posts from people saying ECC is basically required...?
HallofFamer wrote:Hi Guys,
Currently LGA 1150 and Mini-ITX form factor
Budget: $500 pm $100
Usage: Dedicated NAS for file sharing, streaming to devices, and data backup
Timeframe: Next month or so unless there is upcoming technology worth waiting for. Not in any rush.
I buy from Newegg, Amazon, and TigerDirect
The build focus so far has been on compactness and low power consumption. I want to leave this NAS device on 24/7 and later on put together a HTPC. I also haven't decided on the OS. I have experience with ubuntu server, but I have also read about freeNAS. I'm not fond of dedicating a hard drive to the OS or plugging in a USB stick all the time. Looking to do RAID 1 w/ 2x2TB.
CASE - Fractal Design Node 304 [$55]
I really like the sleek look of this case and the 6 drive bays for expansion and air flow.
STORAGE - WD Red NAS 2TB [$200]
I had a hard time picking this over the 5 year warranty on the WD black HDD. I assume the WD red is better optimized for the NAS application and will draw less power when idle.
CPU - Pentium G3220 3.0GHz 54W [$70]
**Updated CPU choice based on Wirko's research.
MOBO - ASUS H87I-PLUS [$115]
Pretty much the only LGA 1150 Mini-ITX motherboard with 6 sata connections built in.
PSU - Antec EarthWatts Green EA-380D 380W [$45]
The approximate peak power draw with 6 HDDs was less than 300W. I targeted a 80% peak loading to be safe (300W/.8 = ~380W).
The reason I am posting this here and asking for help is because most of my builds have focused on gaming/raw power. As such I'm not as confident on where to invest to get the performance i'm looking for. I've also never dealt with NAS, however I currently have a running Ubuntu Server box. I'm open to any comments/suggestions!
Thanks