When Nvidia unveiled its next-gen Tegra, code-named Kal-El, a couple of days ago, it showed the upcoming chip outperforming a Core 2 Duo T7200 in an multi-threaded benchmark running on Android. While the result appeared impressive, I cautioned that the test had been picked and run by Nvidia. Well, the folks at Ilsistemista.net have done a little testing of their own, and they've concluded that the Nvidia numbers are seriously skewed.
The main issue, as the Nvidia video shows in small print, is that the benchmark run on Kal-El was compiled using a recent version of GCC (4.4.1) with aggressive optimizations, while the Core 2 was given a benchmark compiled with looser optimizations using GCC 3.4.4. Ilsistemista attempted to reproduce the results, grabbing a Core 2 Duo T7200-powered Dell laptop and running the same benchmark twice: first compiled with GCC 3.4.6 using the "normal" O2 flag, then with GCC 4.4.4 and the O3 flag.
The results speak for themselves. Performance apparently surged by 41% with the newer GCC release set with more aggressive optimizations. Sticking that result in Nvidia's chart as Ilsistemista did, we can see the Core 2 Duo T7200 actually outpaces Kal-El by a decent margin.
Now, these new numbers don't necessarily detract from Kal-El's appeal, especially since the Core 2 probably consumes many times more power. Nevertheless, while we've come to expect hardware makers to hand-pick tests that show their products in a positive light, the evidence suggests Nvidia went a step further here by not showing the best possible performance of the Intel config. Disappointing.
|The TR Podcast 158: Planet of the Shield Tablets||1|
|Firefly MMO to bring series cast back together||20|
|Friday night topic: your top movies?||192|
|Deal of the week: Corsair's 750D case and four fans for $100||20|
|Android on x86: A quick look at Asus' Memo Pad ME176C tablet||47|
|Triple-wide radiator defines Thermaltake's new water cooler||52|
|Report: Google proceeds with $1 billion Twitch.tv buyout||35|
|The new new name for the UI is called Retro.||+40|