Toolin' along with Tualatin


— 12:57 AM on August 23, 2001

Many of you guys got grumpy about the fact we used CAS 3 memory in our Tualatin review. I guess my penchant for buying really, really cheap memory caught up to me when I skimped on a test box. To make up for it, I ordered up a stick of (relatively) expensive Infineon SDRAM rated to 2-2-2 at 150MHz. That's the DIMM we used for testing the Duron, 1GHz T-bird, Celeron, and Tualatin for our review of the "Morgan" Duron 1GHz. If you want to see how the 1.2GHz PIII "Tualatin" performs with faster RAM, go read the Duron review.

Here's a quick summary of the difference between the cheap RAM and the good stuff: Stream memory bandwidth scores rose considerably, while Winstones added a point or two. Quake III scores jumped nearly 20 points, and 3DMark 2K1 scores went up almost 200 points. In other words, the difference is nothing to sneeze at. If you're buying PC133 SDRAM, buy the good stuff—the 256MB stick I bought was only 46 bucks. (Personally, though, I'd be buying PC2100 DDR memory.)

That said, the PC133 SDRAM-based "Morgan" Duron still smacks down the PIII in Stream tests by about 140-150MB per second. Both chips have hardware prefetch logic to boost memory performance, but the PIII is stuck riding a very slow bus.

 
   
Register
Tip: You can use the A/Z keys to walk threads.
View options

This discussion is now closed.