Super Talent warned us that the IDE Flash drive's transfer rates weren't anything to write home about, and they were certainly right. Sequential transfers are much slower than even our 4,200-RPM mobile ATA drive, with write performance lagging behind reads by a considerable margin. That proves disastrous for the drive's performance in FC-Test, and likely also contributes to its sluggish showing in certain WorldBench component tests.
Despite its poor transfer rates, the IDE Flash drive showed its potential in our iPEAK multitasking tests. The drive also dominated IOMeter's file server, web server, and workstation test patterns. Clearly, there's some value to flash memory's blazing-fast access times, thanks to the banishment of the mechanical latency associated with platters and heads. The drive's nonexistent noise levels and minimal power consumption also have considerable appeal.
Unfortunately, the IDE Flash's most attractive attributes don't match up all that well. Silent operation and low power use would make this thing ideal for laptops, but slow transfer rates and a low WorldBench score blunt its appeal considerably. The IDE Flash drive's real performance potential lies with applications that, like IOMeter's server-oriented test patterns, take advantage of its quick access times. Those applications seem less likely to benefit significantly from lower noise levels or power consumption, though.
In the end, Super Talent's IDE Flash drive is an intriguing alternative to 2.5" ATA hard drives, but probably not one that's likely to have widespread appeal. Fortunately, the drive isn't prohibitively expensive—4 GB versions are selling for under $200 online, with 8 GB models at about $320, and 16 GB flavors running closer to $530. Those prices make the IDE Flash drive affordable enough for niche applications like ruggedized notebooks, silent media center systems with remote storage, and even automotive applications. We just wouldn't drop one into an everyday business notebook.
105 comments — Last by DStauffer at 6:58 AM on 01/22/07
|1. davidbowser - $501||2. cmpxchg - $500||3. GKey13 - $500|
|4. punkUser - $302||5. Ryszard - $301||6. danny e. - $263|
|7. End User - $261||8. Ryu Connor - $250||9. CheetoPet - $250|
|10. dashbarron - $222|
|Intel's 730 Series solid-state drive reviewedAn overclocked enterprise SSD for enthusiasts||68|
|The SSD Endurance Experiment: Data retention after 600TBA three-week reprieve from the onslaught||98|
|The SSD Endurance Experiment: 500TB updateHalfway to a petabyte||97|
|Clash of the terabyte titans: Crucial M500 960GB vs. Samsung 840 EVO 1TBThe best values at the top of the market||71|
|The SSD Endurance Experiment: Testing data retention at 300TBA new wrinkle on the long road||109|
|WD's Black² notebook drive combines 120GB SSD with 1TB HDDTwo shades of the new Black||36|
|OCZ's Vector 150 solid-state drive reviewedHere we go again||39|
|The SSD Endurance Experiment: 200TB updateThe first bad blocks appear||97|
|Somehow this translates into a dual-Hawaii card, right?||85|
|Amazon Prime gets a price hike; Google Drive gets a price cut||28|
|Report: Microsoft waives Windows Phone fees for Indian handset makers||25|
|Mozilla showcases Unreal Engine 4 running in Firefox with no plugins||31|
|Latest Snowden leak suggests the NSA can deploy and manage malware on massive scale||41|
|Unreal Engine 4 game, freemium credits populate new GeForce bundles||16|
|Introducing TR subscriptions||472|
|GeForces 800M series combines Maxwell, Kepler||19|
|We're gonna break the site for a while||57|
|The uncompressed audio sounds AMAZING over my $5000 speaker wire. It's truly worth every gigabyte.||+57|