I wasn't about to drop that kind of cash on an iffy product, so I was seriously considering another alternative. HP now sells a 30" LCD that comes with three DVI inputs and can switch between them. I'd almost rather pony up the $1300 or so for this monitor than $600-something for the Gefen switch. At least then, you're getting a nice display for your money, as well. The expense isn't hard to justify given the amount of lab time we can waste by running only one GPU test rig at a time. Some of our tests, like scripted 3DMark benchmarks, can be run concurrently on multiple systems. Given the breadth of hardware we test, we're talking about saving hundreds of hours in a month or two, merely by moving from one active test system to two.
That's still not exactly a cheap ticket to a simple input-switching capability, so before I pulled the trigger, I decided to look around once more online to see if any new DVI-D KVM switches were available. That's when I discovered the Belkin Flip-DVI-D. This cute little device seemed to be tailor-made for our needs: it's a dual-port switch that handles four kinds of inputs: USB keyboard, USB mouse, analog audio, andgloriously!dual-link DVI. Belkin claims to have designed it for users of Apple's 30" Cinema Display, a cousin to our Dell 3007WFP. Best of all, it was only $125 at Dell's online store. Sounded like a no-brainer to me. Belkin is a big name brand, so surely the quality would be there, unlike the quirky Gefens. I ordered one on the spot.
When the Flip-DVI-D arrived, my first impressions of it were positive. The design of the device is slick and sensible. The cables needed to connect it to the two computers come permanently attached to the unit, so there's no question about needing to buy cables separately (a frequent gotcha with KVM switches) or what plugs in where. You can then hide most of the cabling mess behind the desk, because a separate remote control unit houses the one button needed to switch between computers. This remote also houses a single LED that glows either green or yellow, indicating which computer is selected. All of this makes perfect sense, with no unnecessary complications.
When I fired up the computers connected to the Flip-DVI-D, however, my hopes for this product were quickly deflated. The Flip-DVI-D fails quite visibly at its primary mission: passing through a DVI-D signal from a computer to a monitor. The video signal just doesn't make it to our Dell 3007WFP display intact. At best, the screen is readable, but has quite a few flashing and discolored pixels distributed around it. At worst, the video signal drops out, and the screen goes black. Sometimes, the thing will go from bad (but usable) to worse (black screen) while you're using it, for no apparent reason, and never recover.
I found complaints about this exact problem in a user review of the Flip-DVI-D at Dell's website, so I knew I wasn't alone, but I was determined not to give up hope too soon. I tried a whole range of different video cards to see if that affected things, and I found it really doesn't. Some video cards seemed to be worse than others, but the Flip-DVI-D didn't pass through a clean signal from any of them. My next step was to order a 3' DVI-D cable from Newegg, to see if that would help. Perhaps the longish cable that came with the 3007WFP combined with the Flip-DVI-D's cables added up to too much length and too little signal strength. If so, a shorter cable might do the trick, right? Nope. The 3' cable was no help at all. It may even have been a little worse.
To date, I've found no solution to the Flip-DVI-D's video signal problems, and I'm not sure what else to try. I confess that I've not been through the motions with Belkin tech support, but I'm not optimistic about their ability to fix such a fundamental problem on a closed-box device.
This thing is less than ideal for other reasons, too. The switch is evidently not compatible with HDCP, for one. I wasn't able to play back HD DVD movies on a PC attached to it. Also, switching between inputs involves a long delayfive to ten seconds, at least, sometimes longerbefore the PC figures out that the keyboard and mouse have been reconnected. USB KVM switches seem to be inherently pokey about control switching, but the Flip-DVI-D is inordinately slow even for a USB KVM switch. Drives me crazy.
So I guess you could say my experience with the Belkin Flip DVI-D is pretty much a total failure. I love the product conceptan affordable, easy-to-use DVI-D KVM switch with a snazzy designbut the execution kills it. The thing just doesn't work right.
53 comments — Last by pughwe3000 at 9:07 PM on 01/13/09
|1. GKey13 - $650||2. JohnC - $600||3. davidbowser - $501|
|4. cmpxchg - $500||5. DeadOfKnight - $400||6. danny e. - $375|
|7. the - $360||8. rbattle - $350||9. codinghorror - $326|
|10. Ryu Connor - $325|
|TR's April 2014 peripheral staff picksOur new companion to the TR System Guide||89|
|Cooler Master's QuickFire Stealth mechanical keyboard reviewedA different take on the tenkeyless formula||25|
|Cooler Master's QuickFire Ultimate mechanical keyboard reviewedBeefy, basic, and backlit||70|
|Logitech's K400 wireless keyboard and touchpad reviewedComfortable in the living room||37|
|A first look at Nvidia's G-Sync display techWe lean too far toward the screen, fall in, and don't want to come out||204|
|Topre's Type Heaven mechanical keyboard reviewedMechanical switches with a twist||45|
|Live blog from day two of Nvidia's Montreal 2013 eventThis one should be interesting||32|
|Gigabyte's Aivia Osmium mechanical keyboard reviewedCherry MX switches meet USB 3.0||22|
|Wait, we're giving away $1500 in PC hardware?||7|
|Micro-bots are spooky cool, could be used in manufacturing||11|
|Nvidia GeForce 337.61 beta hotfix display driver released||10|
|AMD earnings previewed||24|
|Ars Technica reviews Windows Phone 8.1||37|
|Steam usage patterns reveal shameful number of unplayed games||60|
|Google buys Titan Aerospace||16|
|What's next after Google Glass? Try Google contact lenses||8|
|Major smartphone makers to integrate kill switches into future mobile devices||21|