We'd neglected to test this config in part because, honestly, we didn't expect the G965/E4300 combo to deliver results in the same class as the X2 BE-2350/690G pairing. Some of our previous tests had suggested that motherboards based on the G965 chipset drew more power than AMD 690G boards.
Intel confidently claimed its solution was competitive, though, and suggested we test and see for ourselves. That only seemed fair to me, so I decided to give it a shot.
The results are below. We tested the E4300 on an Intel DG965WH motherboard with the same basic configurations and methods used in our Athlon X2 BE-2350 review, logging power over time while the system rendered a scene in Cinebench using multiple threads. I suggest looking over that review for complete info on how we tested.
I've included results from several different Core 2 Duo E4300 configs, including:
We'll start with a graph of the raw data over our 60-second test period.You can see right away that the E4300/G965 combo with integrated graphics gives the AMD systems a run for their money. The Intel platform uses a little more power at peak and at idle, and the E4300 takes a tad longer to render the scene, but the contest is a close one. Let's slice and dice the data and bring our whole range of CPUs into the mix. The E4300/G965 team draws only 5W more at idle than the XE BE-2350/690G. When the CPUs are busy rendering the scene, the gap between E4300/G965 and the X2 BE-2350/690G narrows to 4Wcloser than ever. The difference between the X2 BE-2350/690G and the E4300/G965 in total energy consumed over our 60-second test period adds up to about 400 joulesnot a lot in the grand scheme, especially considering that the worst offenders are consuming 10-15K joules during this span of time. The gap between these two configs in energy needed to render the scene is also about 400 joules, and again, it is a proportionally small difference, though not insignificant.
These results don't really alter our original estimation of the Athlon X2 BE-2350 and 690G chipset combo. AMD has achieved a smaller power footprint than the competition by offering a CPU specifically tailored for low-power applications, and we're pleased to see that development. At its price, the BE-2350 remains a bargain.
We've learned, however, that the Core 2 Duo E4300 and G965 chipset can also form the nucleus of a very power-efficient system, one that nearly rivals AMD's low-power desktop platform. That's true in spite of the fact that the Core 2 Duo E4300 isn't billed as an especially low-power part like the Athlon X2 BE-2350 is. That's an impressive result, in my view, and a testament to the overall power efficiency of Intel's standard desktop Core 2 Duo processors and their supporting chipsets.
58 comments — Last by Kent_dieGo at 1:21 PM on 01/04/08
|AMD's Carrizo brings power savings to mainstream laptopsExcavator and GCN combine at 15W||83|
|Intel's Broadwell goes broad with new desktop, mobile, server variants14-nm chips for everyone||166|
|The TR Podcast bonus video: AMD, Zen, Fiji, and moreWith special guest David Kanter||54|
|AMD: Zen chips headed to desktops, servers in 2016Details of its new x86 CPU and plans revealed||250|
|Inside ARM's Cortex-A72 microarchitectureThe next-gen CPU core for mobile devices and servers||42|
|Semiconductors from idea to productThe story of how chips are made||54|
|Intel's Xeon D brings Broadwell to cloud, web servicesA big compute node in a small package||40|
|AMD previews Carrizo APU, offers insights into power savingsExcavator cores and other innovations to help improve efficiency||115|
|The TR Podcast 179: Radeon R9 Fury X tested & dissected||5|
|F1 2015 revs up with new teaser trailer||8|
|Fractal Design's Define S case reviewed||15|
|Microsoft adds $1,299 Core i7 version to Surface Pro 3 lineup||43|
|Nvidia's 353.38 hotfix driver fixes Chrome crashes, G-Sync lag||31|
|Samsung and LG show off battery technology improvements||20|
|Arkham Knight gets first patch, improvement plans||52|
|Samsung will patch its software to restore Windows Update settings||44|
|OnePlus will launch its new phone in virtual reality||19|