Being an Apple keyboard, this aluminum and plastic contraption is designed to pair up with Mac minis, iMacs, and Mac Pros. I don't have any of those systems lying around, however. I just plugged the device into my Windows 7-powered desktop PC.
Thanks to the wonders of the USB standard, Windows happily detects and lets you use the Apple keyboard without any fuss. However, you'll come to realize sooner or later that Mac keyboards aren't quite identical to their PC cousins. Specifically, there are no Windows keys, the control and alt keys sit side by side with an Apple-specific "command" key, several special keys (like print screen and insert) are missing, the F-keys go all the way up to F19 as they extend over the numeric keypad, and the numpad itself is arranged a little differently, with the * symbol in the corner with both - and + below it.
This screenshot from Mac OS X's Keyboard Viewer app provides a good overview of the layout. If you're wondering about that gap next to the F12 key, there isn't onethe Apple keyboard has an "eject" key in that spot. (No, it doesn't do anything in Windows out of the box.)
By default, the Windows key maps itself to the Command key, and the "clear" button on the numpad works as the num lock. If you want print screen, scroll lock, or other PC-specific keys, though, you'll need to install some type of third-party software. Apple's own Boot Camp drivers might be a good start, since Apple wrote them to make sure Mac users could do everything they needed in Windows. Problem is, Apple doesn't distribute those drivers on its website. Your best bet is to borrow a friend's OS X 10.5 or 10.6 installation disc or just to Google around a little bit for the Boot Camp driver package. You'll find something.
The Apple drivers let you use secondary media functions imprinted on some F keys. Be that as it may, I'm not so crazy about Apple's Windows software, so I've personally opted to use AutoHotkey. It costs nothing, consumes just over 1MB of RAM, and lets you re-assign keys yourself via a small configuration file. Here's what mine contains:
Translation: I swapped the alt and command keys on both sides of the space bar, and I bound F13 to print-screen. I still can't use the insert, scroll lock, or media keys, but I don't have much of a need for them.
So, is this keyboard actually any good? Two weeks ago, I would have said no. Two weeks before that, I would have said yesbut only if you use a couple of half-height CD jewel cases to prop up the front end. It's weird, but my satisfaction with this keyboard seems to have followed a sort of inverted bell curve over time.
I was initially pretty happy with it, but the angle quickly became a problem, and I started to get tingling sensations in my wrists after long typing sessions. Propping up the front end helped, since it made the keyboard feel flatter, like the one on my MacBook. I eventually got sick of that and decided to switch back to my IBM Model M. Re-adjusting was difficult, though. The Model M's keys just seemed too high up, and my wrists had trouble finding their old position.
I begrudgingly decided to give the Apple keyboard a second chance. I'm now typing this review on it, and it seems pretty much fine. No wrist tingling, no discomfort, no problems. The low resistance and short travel time provide a nice, sharp feeling, and typing feels more effortless than on any proper desktop keyboard I've tried before.
As with all low-profile keyboards, however, this one has a few unavoidable shortcomings. The general flatness means your fingers are the only things making contact, so it's easy to start typing at the wrong angle or on the wrong set of keys by accident (hunt-and-peck types probably won't have that second problem). The short travel distance makes it a little too easy to press keys too vigorously and tire yourself out, as well.
Apple's aluminum keyboard also has a couple of unique issues. One of them is the caps-lock key, which Apple has rigged not to register very brief keystrokes, purportedly to "reduce accidental activation." That's all well and good, except I regularly run into problems when typing acronyms: it'll ignore the first caps-lock keystroke and register the second, so the acronym will come out in lower-case and the text following it will be in all-caps (think "amd's NEW rADEON hd 5870 IS PRETTY FAST"). I realize some view the caps-lock key as a pointless waste of space, but trust me, it comes in handy when you're typing computer-related acronyms all day.
Also, there's a little, ahem, security issue you should be aware of. Someone at this year's Black Hat security conference figured out (PDF) how to load a keylogger into the Apple keyboard's firmware. Such a keylogger could be difficult to detect, and since it would reside in the actual keyboard, it would survive a hard-drive wipe. This is definitely something to be aware of, but I'm not too worried. Let me explain.
According to Ars Technica, the keylogger can only be installed on an already-compromised computerso, someone would need to have complete access to your system either physically or via a Trojan horse before being able to do anything. At that point, you can kiss your privacy goodbye either way. Second, I've yet to hear of such a keylogger appear in the wild as a genuine security risk. Finally, I would expect any real-world implementations to target Mac OS X, and I'm using this keyboard in Windows 7. I think I'll live. Users more paranoid than I (or with more stringent security requirements) may wish to shop for another keyboard until a fix comes out, however.
I didn't expect to ever say this, but I like the Apple keyboard. Oh, sure, that statement completely ruins my street cred with the clicky keyboard crowd, but what can I say? Mechanical switches work fantastically in full-size desktop keyboards, but laptop keyboards are becoming a fact of life as notebook computers eclipse desktops in popularity. If you like typing on a particular type of laptop keyboard, is it so wrong to get a similar desktop device?
I don't expect the Apple keyboard to last anywhere near as long as my old Model M has, and I don't expect to keep using it indefinitely. Right now, though, I'm just enjoying the ride, and it's nice to be able to type without deafening everyone during conference calls and podcast recording sessions. Germophobes will no doubt appreciate the chiclet design for other reasons, too: if a crumb falls between keys, I no longer go "oh well." I simply brush it off of the aluminum backplate, and that's the end of that. (Good thing, too, because popping off those scissor-switch keys is a scary experience.)
Should you blow $49 on this slab of aluminum and plastic? I definitely wouldn't recommend it unless you've already tried a good chiclet keyboard and liked it. These things aren't for everybody, and since I found this device to have a lengthy learning curve (or habituation curve, at least), many users may simply hate it. You might say this is the kind of keyboard you either love or hateyou know, kind of like Apple products in general.
69 comments — Last by waffle911 at 7:12 PM on 10/26/09
|1. GKey13 - $650||2. JohnC - $600||3. davidbowser - $501|
|4. cmpxchg - $500||5. DeadOfKnight - $400||6. danny e. - $375|
|7. the - $360||8. rbattle - $350||9. codinghorror - $326|
|10. Ryu Connor - $325|
|TR's April 2014 peripheral staff picksOur new companion to the TR System Guide||89|
|Cooler Master's QuickFire Stealth mechanical keyboard reviewedA different take on the tenkeyless formula||25|
|Cooler Master's QuickFire Ultimate mechanical keyboard reviewedBeefy, basic, and backlit||70|
|Logitech's K400 wireless keyboard and touchpad reviewedComfortable in the living room||37|
|Topre's Type Heaven mechanical keyboard reviewedMechanical switches with a twist||45|
|Gigabyte's Aivia Osmium mechanical keyboard reviewedCherry MX switches meet USB 3.0||22|
|A first look at Cherry's MX green key switchesEat your heart out, buckling springs||57|
|TR's 2012 Christmas gift guideWhat's on our lists... and what should be on yours||88|
|Samsung's 28'' display serves up single-tile 4K at 60Hz for $800||109|
|Good Friday Shortbread||7|
|Friday night topic: where are the good ultraportables?||34|
|Deal of the week: Radeon R9 290X cards for... more than list?||17|
|Release roundup: Bits, pieces, and whole PCs||23|
|AMD posts another loss but beats Wall Street forecast||60|
|GlobalFoundries licenses Samsung process tech, grants AMD access to FinFETs||95|
|MSI shows next-gen Intel motherboards||42|