The third dimension
Much like Corsair's SP2500 set with its DSP remote, Antec's Soundscience Rockus 3D|2.1 speakers have some special sauce that sets them apart from the crowd. The special sauce in this case puts the "3D" in "Rockus 3D," and it has a name: 3Dsst. Here's what the technology is all about, in Antec's words:
3Dsst™ is a suite of DSP (digital sound processing) algorithms that create a virtual surround sound experience from 2.1 stereo speakers. The technology analyses the frequency content and pan/positioning of sounds in the incoming audio stream, and then uses certain types of filtering and phasing to widen the sound stage and create the effect of listening to a much larger surround speaker system.No software installation is involved. You need only push the small, gray button on the front of the remote to toggle 3Dsst on and off. (In case you're wondering, the top part of the remote serves to adjust the volume when turned, and it mutes the output when pushed down.)
Now, here's where things get confusing. 3Dsst doesn't map 5.1-channel source audio to the two speakers with fancy virtualization algorithms, even if you hook up the speakers with an optical link. There's not even any support for Dolby Digital audio. Instead, Antec tells us the digital signal processor "uses an algorithm to simulate and accentuate the stereo input."
The truth of the matter is that the Rockus 3D speakers don't really have much 3D going on—they just include a toggle that attempts to create a broader sound stage out of stereo audio. I found that fact a little disappointing, especially considering the prevalence of 3D virtualization technologies like Dolby Headphone, which allow stereo headsets to emulate multiple channels when fed 5.1 audio. Even some versions of Realtek onboard audio offer proper 3D virtualization that supports both headphones and stereo speakers. Such technologies don't always yield perfect results, but there's at least a semblance of an effort there. I can't help but feel like the "3D" label on these Antec speakers is a bit like a Ferrari logo superglued to a red Pontiac Solstice.
And now, ladies and gentlemen, the moment of truth. Specifications and bullet points are one thing, but ultimately, a speaker setup's chief task is to sound good. To check whether the Soundscience Rockus 3D|2.1 meets that criterion, I put it through the paces during a number of gaming, movie-watching, and music-listening sessions. Since the optical connection seemed to yield slightly better, more natural sound, that's what I used throughout my testing. iTunes was used for music playback.
Much to my surprise, the Rockus setup sounded quite a bit better with 3Dsst disabled in Valve's Left 4 Dead 2 (a game I also played to test the Corsair speakers). The game's audio pipeline gave me a reasonably good idea of where sounds were coming from with the speakers in their default mode, but enabling 3Dsst made sound effects harder to pinpoint, and it added a boomy quality to the audio—even with the subwoofer turned down to its lowest setting.
Would 3Dsst perform better in movies? I first tried Avatar, where the 3D mode did in fact succeed in expanding the soundstage and making action scenes pop out of the screen somewhat. That said, the boominess remained, and it became distracting during dialogue-heavy scenes. In Tron Legacy, which has an audio track composed chiefly of dialogue and excellent electronic music, 3Dsst just sounded plain worse than the regular mode.
For music testing, I dug up six of my favorite tracks—four from physical CDs and two from the iTunes Store—and listened closely at a reasonable volume while taking notes. I left the 3Dsst setting disabled throughout.
Overall, I'd say the Soundscience Rockus 3D|2.1 speaker set produces solid mids and sufficient separation between different frequencies—unlike some competitors, like Corsair's SP2500, which seem to squish layered songs into the high end of the spectrum. That said, Antec loses points by giving highs a somewhat metallic, static-like quality and making the bass far too prominent. I had the subwoofer set to the lowest of its three settings throughout my testing, and loud, boomy bass still posed a problem. There really ought to be at least one additional setting below that one. Even if you like your bass thumpy and over-the-top, having the option to tone it down at night will probably make your neighbors happy.
As for the 3Dsst mode, which Antec seems to think important enough to call these "3D" speakers, I've got one thing to say: why? Why would you create a mode to turn stereo audio into slightly different-sounding stereo audio, when surround virtualization schemes exist? The whole point of 3D audio is to provide positional cues, but these speakers offer none of that—and 3Dsst's filtering can negatively impact audio quality to boot.
The Rockus 3D speaker set has other, albeit more minor shortcomings. I would have enjoyed a headphone port, for one. Also, after about five minutes of inactivity, the speakers go into a sort of power-saving mode... which causes an audible and somewhat disconcerting pop. Finally, seeing your distorted reflection in the chrome-plated bezel around the satellites is a bit distracting. I wish Antec had gone with a matte finish there.
All in all, Antec's first stab at the PC speaker market is a commendable but imperfect one, much like Corsair's SP2500. If you put a gun to my head and made me choose a daily driver out of the two, I'd probably go with the Rockus set (in its default, non-3D mode), simply because it renders most music in a more neutral way. I expect good things from both companies' second-generation offerings, though, especially if they take negative user feedback into account.
29 comments — Last by RobbyBob at 12:31 PM on 06/07/11
|1. GKey13 - $650||2. JohnC - $600||3. davidbowser - $501|
|4. cmpxchg - $500||5. DeadOfKnight - $400||6. danny e. - $375|
|7. the - $360||8. Ryszard - $351||9. rbattle - $350|
|10. Ryu Connor - $350|
|TR's August 2014 peripheral staff picksMonitors, monitors, monitors!||53|
|A quick look at Diamond's Xtreme Sound XS71HDUA sound card to go||71|
|TR's April 2014 peripheral staff picksOur new companion to the TR System Guide||89|
|Asus' budget Xonar DGX and DSX sound cards reviewedAffordable PCIe options for discerning ears||131|
|A look at hardware video transcoding on the PCPerformance and image quality with black boxes and OpenCL||46|
|Asus' Xonar U3 USB audio deviceOur favorite sound card thinks outside the box||20|
|Corsair's Gaming Audio Series SP2500 2.1 speakersHope you've got room under your desk...||84|
|A quick listen to Psyko's Carbon surround-sound gaming headsetNew speakers, but better sound?||30|
|The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only two remain after 1.5PB||48|
|Friday night topic: Conspiracy theories||134|
|GeForce 344.11 WHQL drivers support new cards, new games, G-Sync||3|
|Deal of the week: A 23'' IPS monitor for $150, a 200-mm fan for free, and more||23|
|GeForce GTX 970, 980 cards already widely available||25|
|Curved VA panel powers 27'' Samsung monitor||20|
|Android L to encrypt devices by default||7|
|Nvidia's GeForce GTX 980 and 970 graphics cards reviewed||325|