Our recent article comparing the Radeon HD 7950 to the GeForce GTX 660 Ti in many of the season's top new games has attracted some new attention to our latency-focused game testing methods. Some folks are skeptical about whether there's added value to testing with any more granularity than an FPS average would provide. Others have wondered about whether the tool we're using to grab frame time data, Fraps, really captures an accurate reflection of how frames are arriving at the display. There are some interesting questions to explore along those lines, but our intention has always been to illustrate the impact of high-latency frames on animation smoothness visually.
And we can do that quite easily, thanks to the high-speed camera I bought a while back for just that purpose. I've waited much too long to put it to use.
One of the test scenarios with the starkest difference between the GeForce and Radeon in our recent tests is our new Skyrim sequence, where we take a walk through the countryside. You can see the data and graphs we've reported from it here. Neither card performs poorly in this test—the 7950 averages 69 FPS, while the GTX 660 Ti averages 74 FPS—but frame delivery is generally uneven on the Radeon, punctuated by occasional hitches where frames take 60 milliseconds or more to arrive. Such spikes are relatively rare on the GeForce. Here's a look at the frame time plot, which tells the story:
The difference in smoothness between the two cards was obvious as we conducted our play-testing. Since folks were wondering, we figured we might as well capture some high-speed video to show you the difference between the two.
We have a couple videos to share. The first one was filmed at 120 FPS, twice the speed of our 60Hz IPS display. I recommend hitting the "view full screen" button to get a better sense of motion.
I think the occasional hitches on the Radeon are pretty easy to see. The big, obvious slowdowns only happen every so often, but the GeForce avoids them—just as the test results told us.
Remember, the Radeon HD 7950 turns in an average of 69 FPS in this very test run, a rate that has been considered "good" in FPS terms for years. This is why measuring frame latencies, not just average rates, is so crucial. FPS averages don't capture what's happening from moment to moment.
The next video was shot at 240 frames per second, four times the speed of the display.
This one is a little more tedious to watch, I'll admit. However, it should provide many hours of entertainment to those who want to do fine-grained visual comparisons between the two cards. The big hitches are still apparent on the Radeon, but here it may be possible to see the superior moment-by-moment smoothness on the GeForce. I dunno. In some ways, I think it's easier to get a sense of the smoothness at full speed than it is in slow motion.
For what it's worth, Cyril recommends staring at the border between the two videos and unfocusing your eyes a bit in order to best monitor motion on both sides at once. Sounds like a recipe for a headache to me.
Anyhow, you now have a little bit of visual evidence to go with the mountains of data we've provided. Make of it what you will.
330 comments — Last by l33t-g4m3r at 5:30 PM on 02/01/13
|Nvidia's GeForce GTX 1050 and GTX 1050 Ti graphics cards unveiledThe everyman's Pascal cards arrive||49|
|Deus Ex: Mankind Divided reviewedThe next augmentation in a classic series||47|
|Examining early DirectX 12 performance in Deus Ex: Mankind DividedWe take a preview build for a spin||85|
|Asus' ROG Strix GeForce GTX 1080 graphics card reviewed Pascal gets a chance to soar||69|
|AMD's Radeon RX 460 graphics card reviewedThe pint-sized Polaris breaks cover||107|
|AMD's Radeon RX 470 graphics card reviewedA lesser star that's just as bright||289|
|AMD reveals the full specs of the Radeon RX 460 and RX 470But pricing remains a mystery||88|
|Gigabyte's GeForce GTX 1080 Xtreme Gaming graphics card reviewedPower Xtreme||56|
|Lenovo ThinkCentre and ThinkPad machines pack AMD PRO APUs||16|
|Seagate 5TB BarraCuda and 2TB FireCuda drives are big and speedy||6|
|Nvidia licenses Rambus' DPA tech for side-channel data leak prevention||5|
|iOS 10.1 update includes portrait mode beta for iPhone 7 Plus||3|
|Biostar belatedly announces GTX 1060 graphics cards||12|
|HyperX Alloy keyboard gets lean and mean for FPS gaming||8|
|AMD drops prices on the Radeon RX 460 and RX 470||50|
|Reports: Radeon RX 470D is a budget Polaris card for China||9|
|Examining reports of slow write speeds on the 32GB iPhone 7||33|
|A real "console monitor" would be 720p @ 30 Hz ;P||+64|