Single page Print

Conclusions
These are still early days for Mantle, but we can already see its ability to reduce CPU overhead rather dramatically compared to Direct3D. That's exactly the sort of innovation folks have wanted to see in PC gaming, and AMD and DICE are already delivering. One would hope this demonstration of a more modern approach to graphics programming would spur others (ahem, Redmond) to innovate in a way that can benefit the entire PC ecosystem.

There's lots of work yet to be done on Mantle. AMD needs to refine its drivers, add some key features, and improve performance scaling for its older GCN-based graphics chips. Meanwhile, in order for Mantle to really gain traction, EA and DICE will have to follow through on their promise to bring the Mantle rendering path to a host of other games based on the Frostbite 2 engine.

Based on these first results, the big beneficiaries of Mantle's proliferation will probably be folks who, for one reason or another, have a PC that isn't built to perform especially well in many of today's games. PCs with slower processors stand to gain the most.

That said, there are already some well-worn paths to very good gaming experiences on the PC today. The Haswell-based Core i7-4770K is faster than the A10-7850K regardless of the graphics API. Switching from AMD's Direct3D driver to Nvidia's will get you more than halfway to Mantle's performance on an A10-7850K, too. AMD would do well to work on improving its Direct3D drivers and CPUs, as well as pursuing Mantle developmentā€”but I'm sure they already know that. I'm happy to see AMD pushing innovation in graphics APIs at the same time.

We'll surely test Mantle's performance on a broader range of CPUs as it matures. I'm curious to play around with different core counts and to see whether low-power chips like Kabini can provide good gaming experiences with Mantle. Our next task, though, will be to see what performance benefits Mantle can deliver in GPU-limited scenarios. Stay tuned for that.

I tweet things on Twitter sometimes.TR

The Tech Report System Guide: May 2017 editionRyzen 5 takes the stage 110
Aorus' GeForce GTX 1080 Ti Xtreme Edition 11G graphics card reviewedThe eagle has landed 33
Corsair's K95 RGB Platinum gaming keyboard reviewedA lean, mean macro machine 15
HyperX's Pulsefire gaming mouse reviewedKeeping it simple the first time out 8
AMD's Radeon RX 580 and Radeon RX 570 graphics cards reviewedIteration marches on 162
AMD's Ryzen 5 1600X and Ryzen 5 1500X CPUs reviewed, part oneGetting our game on 192
EpicGear's Morpha X modular gaming mouse reviewedHave it your way 11
A moment of Zen with David Kanter: The TR Podcast 190Digging into the whys of Ryzen 39