Western Digital's Caviar SE16 is the latest hard drive to jump on the 300MB/s bandwagon, and fortunately, this Caviar is sporting more than just support for a faster Serial ATA interface. The drive also features a beefy 16MB cache and a stealthy all-black aesthetic that's unlike any other hard drive on the market. Curiously, though, Western Digital has elected not to support Native Command Queuing (NCQ) on its latest high-performance desktop drive. Will that decision hurt the new Caviar's chances against the latest NCQ-equipped Serial ATA drives from Hitachi, Maxtor, and Seagate? Let's find out.
Although we'll be focusing our attention on the Caviar SE16, Western Digital has actually updated its entire Serial ATA Caviar SE line to support 300MB/s transfer rates. As far as their spec sheets go, the Caviar SE and SE16 are largely similar. However, a couple of important distinctions differentiate the SE16 from the rest of the Caviar SE family.
|Caviar SE16||Caviar SE|
|Maximum external transfer rate||300MB/s|
|Internal transfer rate||93.5MB/s|
|Average read seek time||8.9ms|
|Average rotational latency||4.20ms|
|Available capacities||250GB||80, 120, 160, 250GB|
|Idle power consumption||8.75W|
|Seek power consumption||9.5W|
|Native Command Queuing?||No|
|Warranty length||One year (Retail)|
Three years (OEM)
Most notably, the Caviar SE16 has 16MB of on-board cache, double that of the rest of the Caviar SE line. The SE16 is also only available in 250GB capacities, which saves cheapskates like me from choosing a drive capacity based on the most favorable cost/gigabyte ratio.
Apart from cache size and capacity, the Caviar SE16's vitals are virtually identical to those of Western Digital's 300MB/s Caviar SEs. Make sure you get the right drive, though, as the model numbers can be confusing. The Caviar SE16's model number is the WD2500KS, while the Caviar SE is tagged as the WD2500JS. What a difference a letter makes.
It's really no surprise that the Caviar SE and SE16 share similar model numbers considering the fact that they both spin 80GB platters at 7,200RPM. The relatively low-density platters are a bit of a surprise, especially considering that Western Digital's competitors have pushed areal densities up to 133GB per platter. Higher areal densities can translate to faster performance by allowing drive heads to access a greater amount of data over shorter physical distances. According to Western Digital, the SE16 is simply an 80GB platter drive with a new logic board.
In addition to snubbing higher density platters, the Caviar SE16 also lacks support for Native Command Queuing (NCQ). Command queuing can improve drive efficiency and potentially performance by intelligently reordering I/O requests to reduce rotational latency, but Western Digital claims that adding NCQ to the SE16 would hurt sequential read and write performance. The fact that Intel's vanilla ICH7 south bridge doesn't support NCQ is also cited as a justification for the SE16's lack of command queuing support, although it's odd that Western Digital would use a mainstream south bridge spec to determine features for its "highest performance" desktop drive.
Moving to warranties, the Caviar SE16 is covered by a three-year pact, but only when bought as a bare drive. Retail drive kits, which are usually more expensive, are inexplicably only covered by a one-year warranty.
Normally, I'd preface our snapshots of the Caviar SE16 with a snooty comment about how it looks like every other hard drive, but surprisingly, it doesn't. The Caviar SE16's look isn't wildly different, but a little goes a long way in a sea of look-alike hard drives.
Western Digital has gone with an all-black motif for the Caviar SE16, which really only involves coloring a normally bare metal plate on the drive. We're hardly slaves to fashion, but the stealthy look is a nice change of pace, and something that modders with case windows will no doubt appreciate.
Flipping the Caviar reveals a little bit of color, although Western Digital hasn't gone so far as to equip the drive with a black logic board. Interestingly, the drive's circuit board faces inward rather than outward, hiding surface-mounted chips from prying eyes.
|Corsair Lighting Node Pro brings light strip control to every PC||8|
|In the lab: Asus' Tinker Board SBC||14|
|In the lab: HyperX's Alloy FPS mechanical gaming keyboard||10|
|Team Group Cardea SSDs are ready to handle the heat||7|
|Gigabyte's Ryzen motherboards are home, home on the range||37|
|Zotac molds GTX 1050s into low-profile tiny terrors||7|
|TR forums spotlight: krazyredboy's crazy simulator PC||14|
|Deals of the week: a high-end Mini-ITX mobo, fast RAM, storage, and more||27|
|Steam Audio SDK promises better surround sound gratis||19|
|Best part of the article? We're flying home with Ryzen review samples as of this writing.||+44|