Personal computing discussed

Moderators: renee, Flying Fox, Thresher

 
ptsant
Gerbil XP
Topic Author
Posts: 397
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 12:45 pm

Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Sat Jan 19, 2019 2:42 am

Hello,

I want to upgrade to ECC for my Ryzen build (currently using 2x16GB cheap 3000C15 RAM). I am a bit confused with the following alternatives:
https://www.samsung.com/semiconductor/d ... 43BB1-CPB/
https://www.samsung.com/semiconductor/d ... 43BB1-CRC/
https://www.samsung.com/semiconductor/d ... 43BB1-CTD/

The first one is probably the worst one. The second is at $220 locally, the third is at $171 (16GB modules, need two obviously).

I believe the second is rated 2400C17 and the third is 2666CL19 (according to the SPD PDF file). But all three are based on Samsung B-die. So theoretically all should clock quite well. I don't understand why the third is considerably cheaper, while it looks better on paper. Is there something I am missing here?
Image
 
derFunkenstein
Gerbil God
Posts: 25232
Joined: Fri Feb 21, 2003 9:13 pm
Location: Comin' to you directly from the Mothership

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Sun Jan 20, 2019 2:21 pm

I see nothing beyond the SPD that would explain why they're all priced differently. I would just get the cheapest one and not look back. And all else equal I'd probably get the 3rd one just because of the extra rated bandwidth. It probably has no practical impact on clocking higher than stock, but I don't overclock my RAM beyond whatever the motherboard detects.
I do not understand what I do. For what I want to do I do not do, but what I hate I do.
Twittering away the day at @TVsBen
 
NovusBogus
Silver subscriber
Graphmaster Gerbil
Posts: 1408
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2013 12:37 am

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Sun Jan 20, 2019 3:24 pm

Any of the three should be fine. Samsung has by far the most confusing and esoteric product listings of any RAM manufacturer, so it's good to not read too much into what you see on their website.
 
ptsant
Gerbil XP
Topic Author
Posts: 397
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 12:45 pm

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Sun Jan 20, 2019 3:54 pm

Thanks for the help. I'll probably get the third option (2666CL19) and save approx $100.

Will update in a couple of weeks when I get the modules.
Image
 
mikewinddale
Gerbil First Class
Posts: 173
Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2017 2:22 am

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Sun Jan 20, 2019 4:15 pm

Wow, that's really weird. On the HTML page, they all say 2133 MHz. It's only on the PDF datasheets that they say 2133, 2400, and 2666 MHz respectively.

So if you hadn't mentioned the datasheets, I wouldn't have even bothered to look. If I were shopping for Ryzen with ECC, I would have just looked at the HTML page, decided it wasn't remotely what I wanted, and just moved on.

I'd be interested to hear about your experience. I just built a Ryzen with ECC, but I went with Kingston RAM. Everyone was telling me that Samsung was the best, but I thought all the Samsung ECC was 2133 MHz because I was just looking at the HTML pages and not the datasheets. People told me it would overclock fine, but I preferred to get something that was factory spec'ed as high as possible. All other things equal, I'd prefer factory over overclock for the same reason I want ECC in the first place.

So in the end, I went with Kingston KSM26ED8/16ME (16GB 2666MHz DDR4 ECC CL19 DIMM 2Rx8 Micron E).
Product page: https://shop.kingston.com/partsinfo.aspx?ktcpartno=KSM26ED8/16ME
Datasheet: https://www.kingston.com/datasheets/KSM26ED8_16ME.pdf
And that's worked fine for me. But I'd be interested to hear your experience with the 2666 MHz Samsung ECC.
Last edited by mikewinddale on Sun Jan 20, 2019 4:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.
 
Mr Bill
Gerbil Jedi
Posts: 1803
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2002 7:00 pm
Location: Colorado Western Slope
Contact:

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Tue Jan 22, 2019 4:19 pm

What motherboard? You might find this Looking-for-ECC-memory-for-AMD-X470-motherboard interesting.
‎07-11-2018 10:28 AM We have heard back from our engineers on this matter. They were able to get in contact with AMD and get a definite answer to your question. What they found out is that your motherboard will turn on and work with ECC memory installed, but it will not utilize the ECC function. AMD said that Raven Ridge only PRO parts (Commercial APU’s) support ECC. The reason that we do not show ECC memory as compatible with your board is because you will have no added benefit of using ECC memory over standard non-ECC.
X6 1100T BE | Gigabyte GA-990FXA-UD3 AM3+ | XFX HD 7870 | 16 GB DDR3 | Samsung 830/850 Pro SSD's | Logitech cherry MX-brown G710+ | Logitech G303 Daedalus Apex mouse | SeaSonic SS-660XP 80+ Pt | BenQ 24' 1900x1200 IPS | APC Back-UPS NS-1350 | WinXP64 Pro
 
just brew it!
Gold subscriber
Administrator
Posts: 53481
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2002 10:51 pm
Location: Somewhere, having a beer

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Tue Jan 22, 2019 4:53 pm

Mr Bill wrote:
What motherboard? You might find this Looking-for-ECC-memory-for-AMD-X470-motherboard interesting.

07-11-2018 10:28 AM We have heard back from our engineers on this matter. They were able to get in contact with AMD and get a definite answer to your question. What they found out is that your motherboard will turn on and work with ECC memory installed, but it will not utilize the ECC function. AMD said that Raven Ridge only PRO parts (Commercial APU’s) support ECC. The reason that we do not show ECC memory as compatible with your board is because you will have no added benefit of using ECC memory over standard non-ECC.

The answer seems to be specifically referring to Raven Ridge though.
Nostalgia isn't what it used to be.
 
ptsant
Gerbil XP
Topic Author
Posts: 397
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 12:45 pm

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Wed Jan 23, 2019 3:46 am

Mr Bill wrote:
What motherboard? You might find this Looking-for-ECC-memory-for-AMD-X470-motherboard interesting.
‎07-11-2018 10:28 AM We have heard back from our engineers on this matter. They were able to get in contact with AMD and get a definite answer to your question. What they found out is that your motherboard will turn on and work with ECC memory installed, but it will not utilize the ECC function. AMD said that Raven Ridge only PRO parts (Commercial APU’s) support ECC. The reason that we do not show ECC memory as compatible with your board is because you will have no added benefit of using ECC memory over standard non-ECC.


I have an Asus Crosshair VI (X370) and the ECC options are visible in the BIOS, so my understanding is that it would work with my 1700X. I believe I've seen people successfully test ECC with other Asus AM4 motherboards (B350 Prime, if not mistaken). Will post my own results from linux tests if/when I get my hands on the modules.
Image
 
just brew it!
Gold subscriber
Administrator
Posts: 53481
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2002 10:51 pm
Location: Somewhere, having a beer

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Wed Jan 23, 2019 6:55 am

I recently picked up an Asus Prime X470-Pro, and will comment regarding the ECC support as soon as I get around to starting the build.
Nostalgia isn't what it used to be.
 
reeeebooo^
Gerbil In Training
Posts: 3
Joined: Fri Feb 15, 2019 7:05 am

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Fri Feb 15, 2019 12:20 pm

Using the 223988 M391A2K43BB1-CRC with succes on a Ryzen 2700, can´t remember what settings though, but stock voltage CL17@3000MHz iirc.
 
ptsant
Gerbil XP
Topic Author
Posts: 397
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 12:45 pm

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Tue Mar 05, 2019 5:31 am

Hello everyone,

I finally got my M391A2K43BB1-CTD DIMMS (2x16GB dual rank, rated 2666/CL19 1.2V) on an ASUS Crosshair VI with a Ryzen 1700X. They replaced a pair of Corsair Vengeance LPX 3000C15 2x16GB (dual rank).

I can confirm that ECC works in both Linux and Windows:
[    6.897998] EDAC amd64: Node 0: DRAM ECC enabled.
[    6.897999] EDAC amd64: F17h detected (node 0).


In windows, the ram is reported as having "multibit ECC".

This is definitely much better quality ram than the previous. I managed to boot at 3200C15 with all settings at auto except voltage, pushed to the "usual" 1.35V instead of stock 1.2V. It had taken me hours of tuning to get the previous RAM at 2933C16 and I had to dive into all sorts of exotic timings in the BIOS sub-sub-menus. I guess it would probably be able to get to 3333MHz or 3400MHz, but at 3200 I feel I already got my money's worth ($360).

Do note that some pages on the internet claim that the ASUS Crosshair does not have ECC support. It appears to me that this is false.
Image
 
just brew it!
Gold subscriber
Administrator
Posts: 53481
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2002 10:51 pm
Location: Somewhere, having a beer

Re: Help me choose correct ECC B-die for Ryzen

Tue Mar 05, 2019 7:54 am

ptsant wrote:
Do note that some pages on the internet claim that the ASUS Crosshair does not have ECC support. It appears to me that this is false.

There was a lot of confusion about ECC support when Ryzen first came out, due to AMD not "officially" supporting it.
Nostalgia isn't what it used to be.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests
GZIP: On