Federal Judge Orders Against Using ChatGPT In Court Proceedings; Asks Lawyers To Check All AI-Generated Content

Federal Judge Orders Against Using ChatGPT In Court Proceedings; Asks Lawyers To Check All AI-Generated Content

Federal Judge Orders Against Using ChatGPT In Court Proceeding

In a recent bizarre incident, a lawyer was found using ChatGPT to research cases for his federal filing. Attorney Steven Schwartz used AI writing tool to work on six cases – individual cases as well as a detailed line-up of the previous events leading to it.

It was later found that the entire thing was imagined by the AI language model. However, this isn’t a huge surprise. After Microsoft collaborated with OpenAI to bring ChatGPT to Edge, many users complained about the bot making up facts, over-exaggerating the details, or simply going off the rails with a sudden emotional outburst.

Something similar happened here – it simply made up facts and hallucinated the details of the cases.

What Is “Mandatory Certification Regarding Generative Artificial Intelligence”?

The wave of criticism that followed along with the nationwide media coverage of this catastrophic federal filing might have already deterred other lawyers from trying their hands at ChatGPT for legal proceedings. However, Judge Brantley Starr, who was handling Schwartz’s case, doesn’t want to take any risk.

The federal site for Texas’s Northern District allows every judge to set their own set of rules for their courtroom. Starr took advantage of the same to create an order about the “Mandatory Certification Regarding Generative Artificial Intelligence.”.

Under this, all attorneys will be required to attest “no portion of the filing was drafted by generative artificial intelligence”. In case it was, it should be “checked by a human being.”

From now on, every lawyer who presents a case before Starr will be required to sign this form and vouch for the authenticity of each part of their filings, including quotations, legal analysis, citations, etc.

It hasn’t been explicitly mentioned if this order is a direct result of the chaos that ensued with Schwartz’s filing. But considering the timeline of the events and the content of this order, it’s safe to draw the connection.

In the age of technology, it might be hard for many to comprehend the necessity of such a step that limits the use of AI in legal proceedings. After all, it could have expedited the process.

As Judge Brantley Starr rightly pointed out, these tools in their current stage are often factually incorrect and biased.

Sure, they are powerful and can be used in many other ways in the legal industry. AI tools can help find errors in a document or guess questions that might be thrown during oral arguments and much more. But legal filings that heavily depend on the accuracy of the data to direct the course of the trial shouldn’t be left to tools.

Not only do they make mistakes, but they’re also under no oath to be unbiased. Think about it, every practicing attorney has had to take the oath to set aside their personal prejudice and beliefs to upload the law. But these AI tools or the developers who created them are under no such obligation.

In that case, how do you know if they can be trusted to create neutral filings? Apple also recently put a ban on the internal use of ChatGPT.

Well, this was just one judge sharing his views on the use of AI in a court of law. We are yet to see if the other judges follow suit or beg to differ.

Krishi Chowdhary Journalist

Krishi Chowdhary Journalist

Krishi is an eager Tech Journalist and content writer for both B2B and B2C, with a focus on making the process of purchasing software easier for businesses and enhancing their online presence and SEO.

Krishi has a special skill set in writing about technology news, creating educational content on customer relationship management (CRM) software, and recommending project management tools that can help small businesses increase their revenue.

Alongside his writing and blogging work, Krishi's other hobbies include studying the financial markets and cricket.

Latest News

Customer Loyalty Major Statistics

Customer Loyalty Stats in 2023: Loyal Customers Spend More!

Crypto News

Top Crypto Gainers on September 28 – COMP, BCH, And MKR

In Q4 2023, the crypto market has settled in a total market cap range slightly exceeding 1 trillion. Meanwhile, Bitcoin continues to dominate the crypto market due to its large...

Crypto News

Analytical Insights Suggest a Potential 7,918% XRP Rally, Targeting $39 Based on Historical Data

In a recent analysis, financial pundits projected an unprecedented 7,918% surge in XRP value. This audacious prediction stemmed from a meticulous examination of historical data and an advanced Z-Score analysis. ...

X Could

X Could Become Profitable Next Year, Says CEO Yaccarino


DarkBeam’s Alarming Data Breach Exposes 3.8 Billion Records

Crypto News

Cardano Price Prediction: ADA Struggles To Enter Uptrend – Will It Drop Further?

Most Influential Tech Innovations

The 10 Most Influential Tech Innovations of the 21st Century