Home Thomson Reuters vs. Ross Intelligence Lawsuit: Jury to Decide Outcome

Thomson Reuters vs. Ross Intelligence Lawsuit: Jury to Decide Outcome

Damien Fisher Crypto Journalist Author expertise
In our content, we occasionally include affiliate links. Should you click on these links, we may earn a commission, though this incurs no additional cost to you. Your use of this website signifies your acceptance of our terms and conditions as well as our privacy policy.

Delaware Federal Judge Stephanos Bibas has ruled that the lawsuit against Ross Intelligence will go to a jury.  The lawsuit alleges that Ross Intelligence unlawfully copied content from Thomson Reuters’ platform, Westlaw, to develop a competing AI-based platform. 

This development has set the stage for trials involving the alleged unauthorized use of data to train AI systems. It also raises crucial questions about the boundaries of data usage in AI development and its potential impact on copyright holders.

Notably, the Reuters report also revealed that tech giants like Meta Platforms, Stability AI, and Microsoft-backed OpenAI are facing similar lawsuits from copyright owners. 

A prominent player in the information services industry, Thomson Reuters, initiated legal action against Ross Intelligence in 2020.  The core of the dispute revolves around Ross Intelligence’s alleged infringement of Westlaw’s “headnotes.” These headnotes serve as concise summaries of legal points within court opinions. 

Thomson Reuters contends that Ross Intelligence misappropriated thousands of these headnotes to train its AI-powered legal search engine. In response to these allegations, Ross Intelligence stated that it had ceased its platform operations in January 2021attributing its decision to the financial burdens of the ongoing legal action.

However, the actual status of the platform still remains unclear. Both parties sought pretrial victories in the case, with Ross arguing that it made fair use of the Westlaw materialThis argument has raised a crucial question regarding the legality of using copyrighted data for generative AI training purposes.

Fair Use in AI Training

One pivotal question central to this case is whether Ross Intelligence’s use of the Westlaw headnotes constituted fair use. Ross asserted that the headnotes were used merely as a means to locate judicial opinions.

And they did not directly compete with Thomson Reuters in the market for the headnotes themselves. In contrast, Thomson Reuters countered that Ross had copied the materials to build a direct competitor to Westlaw. Judge Bibas, in his recent ruling, underscored the complexity of determining fair use in this context. 

He highlighted that it remains unclear whether Ross genuinely transformed the Westlaw material into a distinct research platform or with a different purpose, a critical consideration in fair use assessments. Judge Bibas also recognized a contentious issue concerning the public interest in allowing AI systems to be trained with copyrighted material. 

The ruling has ignited a debate about the broader implications of AI development in relation to copyright protection. Judge Bibas noted that he could not decide whether a verdict favoring Ross or Thomson Reuters would better serve the public interest. As a result, the case will be decided by a jury. 

As the Thomson Reuters vs. Ross Intelligence lawsuit unfolds and heads toward a trial, it presents a glimpse into the future of AI, copyright law, and the ethical considerations surrounding data usage. The outcome of this case will likely have far-reaching implications.

It will shape how tech companies acquire data for AI training. Additionally, it will prompt discussions on balance between innovation and intellectual property rights. Following this development, the legal landscape surrounding AI and data usage is poised for significant evolution.

Damien Fisher Crypto Journalist

Damien Fisher Crypto Journalist

Damien Fisher is a seasoned crypto news writer with a relentless curiosity for blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies. With a career spanning over a decade, Damien has solidified his position as a trusted authority in the industry. Besides contributing insightful articles to TechReport, he also lends his expertise to reputable sites like Invezz and CryptoCoin.News. Through his work, Damien continues to provide valuable information to readers, keeping them informed about the latest developments and trends in the ever-evolving world of cryptocurrencies. His passion for the subject and dedication to accuracy make him a standout figure in the crypto news space.

Latest News

Seasonal Traditions

Seasonal Traditions in Numbers: Statistical Insights into Christmas and New Year’s Celebrations

Google's Image Search Results Flooded With AI-Generated Images

Google’s Image Search Results Flooded With AI-Generated Images

Although Google promised to label AI-generated images to prevent confusion earlier this year, its image search results have become a breeding ground for deceptive AI-generated images. This has raised questions...

Amazon Launches Q AI Chatbot for AWS Customers

Amazon Launches Q, a Sophisticated AI Chatbot for AWS Customers

Amazon is all set to revolutionize the experience for its AWS customers as it braces up to launch a groundbreaking AI chatbot named ‘Q’. Priced affordably at just $20 per...

Price Prediction

Bitcoin Price Prediction: BTC Drops from $38k. Are the Bulls Losing Momentum?

Crypto News

Top Crypto Gainers on November 28 – FTT, TIA, and ROSE


Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Jobs: Assessing the Impact on Wages and Employment


Binance And Its Founder CZ Pay Heavily For Challenging America’s Financial And Political Status Quo