Intel SSD DC P4510 drives promise dense, efficient bulk storage

64-layer NAND meets data-center NVMe

Intel expects that change is coming in the data center. The way the company sees it today, the various parts within today's typical server—CPUs, SSDs or hard drives, memory, and expansion cards—become functionally obsolete at different points within the server's lifespan, ultimately leading to a large cash outlay to replace the entire box at its end of life. Contrast that with the smaller bills involved with replacing the parts that are no longer pulling their weight while keeping what works while the server is still in use.

Racks filled with "converged" servers—those with memory, storage, and computing resources inside—also might employ their storage and computing resources unevenly. The storage capacity within a server or servers might be maxed out, for example, while portions of the compute resources in that same server might sit idle. The bandwidth and latency characteristics of NAND flash could also prove the ultimate bottleneck to getting the most performance out of each server in a rack, as well.

At least for buyers of its storage products, Intel thinks it sees a better way of building up future servers and racks. Instead of continuing to build up racks with today's idea of a converged server, the company believes it can help businesses get more out of each server's compute resources by replacing NAND SSDs with pools of Optane DIMMs and Optane SSDs for "hot" data. The impressive low-latency characteristics and high capacity of Optane devices could lead to as much as 18 TB of virtual memory per server for applications that need both speed and capacity. Meanwhile, NAND flash would be relegated to its own rack units for bulk data storage instead of taking up valuable space within those servers.

The SSD DC P4510 that Intel is unveiling today is meant to be one of the building blocks for those bulk-storage tasks. These drives use Intel's latest 64-layer NAND flash chips to boost both density and performance, and they also benefit from a focus on quality-of-service improvements. The company says it's been shipping tens of thousands of these drives to cloud service providers since the third quarter of last year, and it's now ready to begin shipping them in 4-TB and 8-TB capacities on top of 1-TB and 2-TB models.

Although the DC P4510 offers a claimed 90% increase in raw write bandwidth over its DC P4500 predecessor (for 128K pages at QD128, anyway), that performance increase alone isn't really the important part of this drive's story for its intended audience of data centers and cloud service providers. The bigger improvements are for quality of service and power efficiency. Intel claims as much as a 2x performance-per-watt improvement from the DC P4500 for sequential-write workloads.

On the quality-of-service front, Intel improved the firmware in the P4510 to better prioritize reads over writes when needed and at a finer granularity than that of its past drives. The drive's denser NAND doesn't only allow for higher-capacity SSDs—it also offers lower program latency than the 32-layer stuff in the DC P4500.

Versus the older drives, those improvements cut the DC P4510's read latency at QD1 for four nines (or for 99.99% of IOPS) from 2.24 ms to 0.17 ms and from 4.1 ms to 1.82 ms for a mixed workload of 70% random reads and 30% random writes. The company touted improvements out to six nines (or the 99.9999th percentile), and even at that demanding standard of QoS, the P4510 still delivers a huge improvement over the DC P4500.

Across a range of workloads, Intel believes the P4510 will offer a considerable speedup compared to the P4500. 

Intel's results with the Aerospike certification tool for NoSQL workloads

In a test performed with the Aerospike Certification Tool, which measures a drive's performance as a multiple of a baseline workload of 2000 reads per second and 1000 writes per second and only passes a drive if it services 95% of those IOPS within a millisecond, the DC P4500 offers a 4x result and the DC P4510 turns in a massive 48x score. For analytics workloads, Intel created an internal version of the STAC-M3 benchmark that shows the DC P4510 leading the P4500 in 15 out of 17 of the benchmark tests. In Intel's favorite "write-pressure" torture test of SSD performance, the DC P4510 delivered 3.75x the bandwidth of the P4500.

The density and power-efficiency improvements in the DC P4510 could free up more space and power in a rack for other types of resources, too. Going by the Open Compute Project standard of 12 kilowatts of power per rack and giving over no more than 50% of rack space to storage devices, Intel offers an example of how one can get to 720 TB of storage within those constraints. WIth the company's 2 TB P3520 drives, one would have to give over half the rack to storage units, and the total power consumption of those drives would add up to 4.3 kW—a little over a third of the rack's power budget. Using 8 TB DC P4510s, on the other hand, one would only have to give six rack units over to storage, and those drives would only consume 1.4 kW.

The DC P4510 also improves a number of management and servicing scenarios versus older Intel drives. The P4510 works with the NVMe Management Interface spec, has online firmware update capabilities, and offers namespace management support for shared-storage environtments. On top of those features, Intel says it's standardized the handling of surprise hot-plug-and-insertion events on its Xeon Scalable processor platforms with the DC P4510 in its U.2 form. The company says its older PCIe SSDs required vendor-specific implementations of hot-plug support that were apparently the cause of some headaches. This platform-standard approach comes thanks to a new on-chip unit called the Volume Management Device, or VMD. The VMD also offers a standard method of managing LED indicators to help data center administrators quickly locate and replace failing SSDs.

The VMD isn't the only storage-specific feature baked into Xeon Scalable processors, of course. Virtual RAID on CPU, or VROC, arrived last year with Xeon Scalable processors as well, and Intel thinks it's an ideal complement for DC P4510 SSDs. Intel notes that on its older platforms, customers had to turn to relatively expensive third-party RAID cards to gang together large numbers of SATA SSDs, making the RAID card the bottleneck when the CPU was hungry for data.

The costs of purchasing new platforms aside, Intel claims that using a compatible Xeon Scalable CPU, a $249 VROC key, and four DC P4510 4 TB drives can deliver as much as an 8X increase in IOPS using its test workloads compared to a $700+ discrete LSI 3108 RAID card and 12 Intel S35120 drives. If that's true, VROC could offer a route to higher performance at similar or lower costs. Server OEM Huawei says four DC P4510 drives paired with VROC can deliver 500K IOPS on pure random write workloads in RAID 0, an apparently unprecedented degree of actual versus theoretical performance for such a configuration.

While the DC P4510 is launching in U.2 housings for the moment, Intel thinks the real future of its 3D NAND and the DC P4510 lies in the EDSFF, or Enterprise and Data Center SSD Form Factor. Born out of Intel's Ruler SSD concept from last year, EDSFF lets Intel pack a claimed petabyte of SSD storage in just one rack unit, and the company says it will be able to deploy that density to customers this year. Density isn't the only advantage of EDSFF, however, as Intel says its internal tests of cooling requirements for these drives let it cut airflow—and therefore cooling power usage—by as much as 55% compared to U.2.

All told, the DC P4510 seems poised to serve the needs of cloud service providers and businesses that need massive PCIe SSDs for massive data sets, with their attendant benefits for reliability, power usage, and heat generation. Data-center administrators who want to take advantage of the DC P4510's virtues will likely need to get in touch with server OEMs or channel providers to get pricing and availability info, as Intel only claims that the drive is available now.

Intel's Optane SSD 800P 58 GB and 118 GB solid-state drives reviewed3D Xpoint gets more attainable 69
Intel's SSD 760p Series 512 GB solid-state drive reviewedA value NVMe player gets a 64-layer upgrade 34
Samsung's 860 Pro 1 TB solid-state drive reviewedA delicious 64-layer MLC cake 37
The Tech Report System Guide: winter 2017 editionFresh PCs for every need 62
Intel Optane SSD 900P drives deliver a big chunk of next-gen storage to desktops3D Xpoint SSDs descend from the data center 76
Toshiba's TR200 480GB SSD reviewedBiCS on a budget 26
Adata's SE730H 512GB portable SSD reviewedDurability meets next-gen speeds 6
The Tech Report System Guide: September 2017 editionHog heaven at the high end 100

Tags: Storage