Crytek weighs in on Shader Model 3.0

Far Cry's developers offer their take

AFTER WE PUBLISHED our article about the new Far Cry 1.2 patch late last week, I had the chance to speak to Cervat Yerli, CEO and President of Crytek, the development house that created Far Cry. In addition to his official titles, Yerli served as technical and creative director for Far Cry, so he was one of the principal figures involved in making the game. I asked Yerli about Crytek's efforts in developing the new patch for the game and about working with Shader Model 3.0.

Taking the new model out for a spin
Yerli said that Crytek dedicated a pair of programmers to implementing the Shader Model 3.0 code path in Far Cry, and he said the entire retrofit took three to four weeks to complete. Obviously, implementing Shader Model 3.0 was more complicated than just ticking a checkbox for a new render target in a compiler, but it didn't require a rewrite of the game engine. Some of the changes Crytek made took only a few hours, while other elements of the retrofit took a week or two to complete. In fact, after the first two weeks of effort, Crytek had the initial version of the Shader Model 3.0 code path up and running.

Far Cry, of course, started out with a fairly sophisticated game engine that took advantage of Shader Model 2.0 to deliver per-pixel lighting. Yerli said Shader Model 3.0 doesn't bring any change in visual fidelity, just better performance. In fact, he emphasized the point repeatedly during our conversation. In the case of pixel shaders, lighting some objects covered with shader-based materials using Shader Model 2.0 required multiple passes—one pass per light. If the object were affected by three lights, the pixel would have to take three passes through the rendering pipeline. With Shader Model 3.0, Crytek was able to consolidate its per-pixel lighting work so that up to four lights can be rendered in a single pass.

Shader-based materials with multiple lights are faster with 3.0
(Click for larger version)

Crytek's revamped pixel shaders use branching and looping in order to calculate the effects of multiple lights in a single pass, but the instruction lengths of those shaders don't approach the 96-instruction limits of SM 2.0 pixel shaders. Instead, Yerli stated that the primary benefits of SM3.0 pixel shaders are more constants, tables, and the like, which lead to better performance. The effects you'll see in current games running on today's hardware, in his estimation, can be implemented within the 96-instruction limits of SM2.0; the longer instruction lengths in Shader Model 3.0 won't be practical until the next generation of graphics hardware arrives. For now, he said, SM2.0 will allow the creation of any effect developers want.

Beyond pixel shaders, Far Cry 1.2 uses another Shader Model 3.0 feature, geometry instancing, to accelerate game performance. With geometry instancing, the Far Cry engine can place multiple copies of the same 3D model onscreen at once, each with different attributes, using only one draw call. The game engine automatically uses geometry instancing whenever copies of the same static mesh appear at once. Although this capability primarily provides benefits in areas with lots of grass and foliage, the feature isn't linked to a single model type. In fact, like the pixel shader enhancements, geometry instancing is a game-wide enhancement that requires no change to the game content.

I asked Yerli about the image quality problems on GeForce 6800 cards in version 1.1 of Far Cry. He dismissed those as "just rendering issues" and said that the Shader Model 3.0 path cleaned up those problems. The SM3.0 path does include a mix of FP16 and FP32 datatypes on GeForce 6800 cards for the sake of performance, but Yerli said Crytek never sacrificed image quality for performance, a move that's "not an option" for them. Out of curiosity, I also asked whether he knew of any instances where the use of FP24 precision on ATI cards caused visual artifacts, and he said no.

The skinny on quick-save
As we wrapped things up, I veered off the path a bit to ask another question on everyone's mind: Will Far Cry 1.2 include a revamped save-game system? Yerli said there will be two versions of the 1.2 patch released. Crytek hopes to release the first version within the next week or so. That initial version of the 1.2 patch will not include a quick-save function. Some time later, Crytek plans to release a version 1.2 patch with quick-save enabled. Yerli said building quick-save into Far Cry has been a painful process, because the game wasn't designed with this feature in mind. However, Crytek is fixing bugs daily, and the quick-save patch will be released once all the bugs are squashed. TR

Tags: Graphics Gaming

Analogue Mega Sg reviewed: cloning a Sega Genesis with FPGA powerIt's fun to play on the F-P-G-A! 73
PDP's LVL 50 wireless headset reviewedVenturing out into other rooms 5
The digital game store wars: Who are the players?It's getting crowded 96
All the RTX 2000-series Max-Q laptopsRTX 2070 Max-Q, RTX 2080 Max-Q abound 13
Revisiting the Radeon VII and RTX 2080 at 2560x1440Can a lower resolution turn the tables for AMD? 244
AMD's Radeon VII graphics card reviewedPlus ça change 265
Asus' ROG Strix GeForce RTX 2070 graphics card reviewedTU106 takes fully-fledged flight 56
Logitech G935 7.1 wireless gaming headset reviewedBetter wireless than wired 31